Welcome to Papa Wheelies
Nestled in McKinleyville, CA, Papa Wheelies is a cozy gem known for its mouthwatering burgers and inviting atmosphere. Customers rave about the perfectly cooked, grass-fed beef burgers and the generous, crispy fries served with delicious homemade dipping sauces. The ambiance blends rustic charm with a whimsical touch, showcasing unique decor like etch-a-sketch art and offering board games for a fun dining experience. Locally sourced ingredients, such as the signature lobster mushrooms, elevate the menu, making every bite memorable. With friendly staff and a fine selection of craft beers on tap, Papa Wheelies promises a delightful outing for all food enthusiasts.
Papa Wheelies: Reviews & Ratings
Don’t trust the hours on google! Drive by and see if it’s open; it is absolutely worth your time. We ordered the burger and BLT with fries. Burger was perfectly cooked, sauces were balanced, and bun was nice and toasty. BLT had nice thick bacon, lots of lettuce and tomato. Fries were remarkable - crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside with homemade dipping sauces that were delicious. Nice selection of beer and cider on tap - I tried a couple before settling on a sour plum beer. Atmosphere is cozy creepy chic. Board games to play while you wait for your order (which wasn’t a long time at all). Get yourself in here!
My wife and I stopped here on a whim and loved it. The staff was very friendly and the cheeseburgers very good. Grass fed beef, yum. The ambience is hard to explain, retro and relaxed maybe. Local bar with a great kitchen? This small place oozes charm and the food and people are excellent.
Amazing burgers with fun atmosphere. Be sure to check out the etch-a-sketch art! Also highly recommend their basket of fries and the “lobster mushrooms” if they’re in stock. The mushrooms are locally found in the redwoods.
Edit! New lunch time and menu!!! Absolutely knocked it out of the park! Burger is top tier, the attention to detail is evident! Fries are crispy to the last one. Decor is wild and the play list was awesome. I'm definitely going back soon. You will not have a bad time here!!!
Amazing food and live entertainment!! Came here after our engagement in Tall Trees Reserve and Scott and Ashley was super sweet and enthusiastic! We’ve loved our experience here and will definitely visit again.
Our day started amazing and the afternoon took a big turn. Swung by here to get some beer and burgers to comfort us and boy were we surprised! Scott and Ashley were so welcoming and got to know us a little bit. They were so nice and made the visit worth it based on just that. We had their burger, some Bleu Buffalo wings and some fries. Everything was freshly made and super delicious especially the wings! Thank you for making our engagement dinner a one to remember!
The vibe in here is fantastic. The service was quick and friendly. But most of all, the food was phenomenal. The kitchen is small but the chef did a fantastic job quickly getting out great food. We had the special bacon jam burger, grilled ham and cheese, tomato soup, and bacon cheese fries. We will absolutely be back!
Service was a 10/10, the ladies working here are awesome. They were so accommodating and on top of anything we needed. The burger was one of the best I've had! The cheesy garlic fries are great too. Their homemade fries are tastier than other homemade fries I've had by far. I can't believe I've been driving by this place for years and never stopped, but I'm so glad I did! I highly recommend checking it out.
Location
-
1584 Reasor Rd, McKinleyville, CA 95519, United States Hotline: +1 707-630-5084
Welcome to the vibrant world of Papa Wheelies, a must-visit culinary gem nestled in the charming town of McKinleyville, California. Located at 1584 Reasor Rd, this cozy establishment merges a unique dining experience with a relaxed, retro ambiance, making every visit not just a meal, but a memorable outing.
From the moment you step through the door, you are embraced by a warm and inviting atmosphere, punctuated by intriguing decor and even some playful Etch-a-Sketch art. With an eclectic mix of board games available, you'll find that time spent waiting for your order only adds to the experience. Patrons rave about the friendly staff, who create a delightful sense of community that keeps locals and visitors alike coming back for more.
Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the food. As echoed in multiple reviews, the burgers at Papa Wheelies are a true highlight. Crafted with grass-fed beef, these burgers are perfectly cooked and balanced with delicious sauces on a nice toasty bun. The BLT, generously layered with thick bacon, fresh lettuce, and tomatoes, is another fan favorite. And don't overlook the fries—crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, they come accompanied by homemade dipping sauces that add that extra flair.
If you're a fan of unique beverages, Papa Wheelies offers a nice selection of local beers and ciders on tap. Many visitors enjoy experimenting with different flavors, from refreshing ciders to distinct sour beers, which perfectly complement the food. One customer even listed a sour plum beer as a delightful choice, enhancing the overall dining experience.
The charm of Papa Wheelies goes beyond the food; it's evident that every detail is thoughtfully curated. Reviews mention the live entertainment that adds an enriching layer, elevating your visit from ordinary to extraordinary. From its cozy yet quirky aesthetic to its top-tier American diner fare, this restaurant knocks it out of the park for its patrons.
In conclusion, if you find yourself in McKinleyville, don’t just take Google’s word for it; drive by, and if the lights are on, step inside. Whether you're looking for an amazing burger, an inviting ambiance, or a fun evening with friends, Papa Wheelies is undoubtedly worth your time and taste buds. Prepare to return again and again; once you experience the magic here, it’s hard to stay away.